SmallBizGenius Analysis

Saks Fifth Avenue faces significant criticism regarding its online order fulfillment and customer service. Customers frequently report issues with order accuracy, shipping, and returns, leading to widespread dissatisfaction.

Category Breakdown

Scores based on analysis of 276 recent reviews

Customer Service

1.5/10

Reviewers consistently report negative experiences with Saks Fifth Avenue's customer service. They describe representatives as rude, unhelpful, and unable to resolve issues effectively, often leading to frustration and dissatisfaction. For example, many customers mention difficulty obtaining refunds or exchanges, even when the issue is clearly Saks' fault, and some customer service representatives are reported to be dismissive or condescending.

65 reviews mention this

Shipping and Delivery

2.0/10

A significant number of reviewers complain about issues with shipping and delivery. Common problems include delayed shipments, packages not received, and items delivered to the wrong address. Several reviewers also report receiving damaged or poorly packaged items, which is particularly concerning given the high cost of the products.

58 reviews mention this

Returns and Refunds

1.0/10

Many customers express frustration with Saks Fifth Avenue's return and refund process. Reviewers report difficulties in getting refunds processed in a timely manner, and some claim that their returns were rejected for unclear or false reasons. Several reviewers also mention being charged for return shipping, which they find unreasonable.

48 reviews mention this

Product Quality and Accuracy

2.5/10

Numerous reviewers report receiving incorrect, used, or damaged items. Some customers received items that appeared to have been worn or returned by someone else, while others received products with defects or missing parts. This raises concerns about Saks Fifth Avenue's quality control and order fulfillment processes.

40 reviews mention this

Website and Ordering Issues

3.0/10

Some reviewers mention problems with the Saks Fifth Avenue website and ordering process. These include difficulties with tracking orders, website errors, and confusing or misleading product descriptions. These issues can lead to frustration and a negative shopping experience.

15 reviews mention this

Pros & Cons

What Customers Love

Potential for occasional discounts and promotions. Mentioned 2x
"Sorry to see them go. I buy mostly during the holidays but wish them the best after restructuring."

Common Complaints

Customer service is frequently described as unhelpful and rude. Mentioned 65x
"OMG THEIR CUSTOMER SERVICE IT THE WORST! RUN FROM THIS COMPANY!..... CUSTOMER SERVICE ARE ALSO SO UNPROFESSIONAL.. DONT SOLVE ANY ISSUES, DONT KNOW HOW TO PROPERLY RESOLVE ISSUE... OMG DO THEY CLAIM..."
Shipping is unreliable, with frequent delays and lost packages. Mentioned 58x
"I ordered an item for me to not receive it and Saks’ tracking number not working on FedEx’s website."
Returns are often difficult to process, with refunds delayed or denied. Mentioned 48x
"Saks is not accepting my return even though im well within the return period and the items are not a final sale item."
Product quality is inconsistent, with reports of damaged or used items being shipped. Mentioned 40x
"I ordered a expensive ralph lauren coat. It arrived rolled up in a dry cleaning bag from Saks warehouse!!! It appears to have been worn and wrinkled as the price tag had the preferred price tore off?..."
Orders are often inaccurate, with customers receiving the wrong items or missing parts. Mentioned 20x
"I ordered women’s ASICS tennis shoes in a size 8 and was sent a men’s size 8 instead, which is a 9.5 in women’s."

Common Questions About Saks Fifth Avenue

Answers derived from customer review patterns

Is Saks Fifth Avenue legit and trustworthy?

Based on the 100 Trustpilot reviews analyzed, Saks Fifth Avenue's legitimacy is questionable, particularly regarding its online operations. While Saks Fifth Avenue is a well-known retailer, numerous customers report issues with order fulfillment, product quality, and customer service, suggesting a lack of reliability. Many reviewers claim to have received incorrect, damaged, or used items, and some have struggled to obtain refunds or resolve problems with customer service. These issues raise concerns about the trustworthiness of Saks Fifth Avenue's online shopping experience.

Based on 45 reviews

Does Saks Fifth Avenue have good customer service?

The overwhelming consensus from the reviews is that Saks Fifth Avenue's customer service is poor. Many reviewers describe customer service representatives as rude, unhelpful, and unable to resolve issues effectively. Customers report long wait times, difficulty getting in touch with representatives, and a lack of empathy or willingness to assist with problems. The negative customer service experiences contribute significantly to the overall dissatisfaction with Saks Fifth Avenue.

Based on 65 reviews

Is Saks Fifth Avenue worth it for small business?

Considering the numerous negative reviews, Saks Fifth Avenue is generally not recommended for small business purchases. The high risk of encountering problems with order accuracy, product quality, shipping, and customer service outweighs any potential benefits. Small business owners need reliable vendors and efficient service, and the reviews suggest that Saks Fifth Avenue may not consistently meet these needs. Exploring alternative retailers with more positive customer feedback is advisable.

Based on 70 reviews

What is Saks Fifth Avenue's return policy like?

While Saks Fifth Avenue may have a stated return policy, many reviewers report difficulties in actually getting their returns processed smoothly. Customers claim that refunds are often delayed or denied, and some have been charged for return shipping. Several reviewers also mention that their returns were rejected for unclear or false reasons, leading to frustration and financial loss. The actual return experience appears to be inconsistent and often problematic, despite the stated policy.

Based on 48 reviews

Why are customers complaining about Saks Fifth Avenue?

Customers are complaining about Saks Fifth Avenue due to a combination of issues related to online order fulfillment and customer service. The most common complaints include receiving incorrect, damaged, or used items, experiencing delays or failures in shipping, and encountering difficulties in processing returns and refunds. Many reviewers also express frustration with the unhelpful and rude behavior of customer service representatives. These issues collectively contribute to a negative shopping experience and widespread dissatisfaction.

Based on 85 reviews

Ready to Try Saks Fifth Avenue?

Save on your first purchase with 3 verified coupon codes.

View Coupons

Looking for Something Different?

Compare Saks Fifth Avenue against 522 similar lifestyle & perks options.

View Alternatives